The Choir Crisis: What’s Causing the Decline?

Reading Time: 3 minutes


If your church choir is struggling, you’re not alone. A quick glance around the country shows choirs are in crisis. From difficulties finding committed members to a lack of support from leadership, the traditional church choir is facing some serious challenges.

So what’s going on? Are choirs a dying breed destined for extinction? Not so fast. While it’s true that many churches have phased out choirs in favor of praise teams and bands, there are still plenty of thriving choirs out there. The key is having the right ingredients.

The Importance of Dynamic Choir Leadership

First and foremost, you need a dynamic choir director who’s passionate about the ministry. Lackluster leadership is the death knell for any choir. The director must have a vision and be able to inspire others to buy into it. Making choir fun and spiritually fulfilling is crucial for attracting and keeping members.

Pastor support is another must-have. If the pastor views the choir as mere preliminaries before the sermon, it’s going to be an uphill battle. Choirs really blossom when the pastor prioritizes participatory worship. Congregational singing goes hand-in-hand with a healthy choir. Funny how that works!

Overcoming the Commitment Challenge

Of course, a choir is only as good as its members. And therein lies the rub. It’s harder than ever to get people to commit. In our fast-paced world, people are less willing to devote an evening to choir practice. Older members who’ve been the backbone of choirs are aging out. Younger generations aren’t exactly clamoring to take their place.

Reinventing the Church Choir for the Modern Age

So what’s the solution? Some churches have found success by reinventing their choirs for the modern age. Instead of a performing choir that just does special music, they’ve created a worship choir that functions as an extension of the praise team. Combining the choir with the band and doing newer worship music alongside anthems can breathe new life into a struggling choir.

For churches married to a more traditional format, paring down to a Christmas and Easter choir might be the way to go. People are often more willing to commit to a seasonal choir. Bringing in an orchestra can also add a wow factor that draws in participants and engages the congregation.

Another key to attracting younger members, especially parents of little ones, is providing quality childcare during rehearsals. Let’s face it, getting out of the house is hard enough for sleep-deprived moms and dads. Knowing their kids are being well cared for can make all the difference in their ability to participate. Seriously, this can be a game-changer!

Finding the Right Fit for Your Congregation

At the end of the day, choirs aren’t for every church. It really depends on your congregation’s culture and your worship leaders‘ capability. Trying to force a choir into a resistant environment is like trying to put a square peg in a round hole – frustrating and fruitless. Better to focus on what works for your people.

But if you do sense that your church has the potential for a thriving choir, it’s worth fighting for. There’s nothing quite like the sound of a well-rehearsed choir leading a congregation in heartfelt worship. Hearing that vocal wall of sound encourages congregations to sing out. With prayer, persistence, and the right personnel, your choir can be revitalized from the brink of death.

Bottom line: Choirs aren’t dead – not by a long shot. But they are facing real challenges. If the traditional model isn’t working for your church, don’t be afraid to innovate. Find ways to make choir relevant and engaging for your congregation. Most of all, never underestimate the power of a choir that’s on fire for the Lord.

Stop Leading Worship WRONG…Do THIS Instead!
Guiding Passionate but Pitchy Singers to Their Best Fit

This Week’s Top Songs

Keep track of the top CCLI, Praisecharts, CCM and Hymncharts along with lyrics! There’s nothing like this list on the Internet! Go to the Top Songs page.

Find Hymns That Match Your Favorite Worship Songs

Which hymns go well with Bethel’s Goodness of God? Search at HYMNDEX.COM.

YouTube Worship Playlists!

From Worshipflow editor Don Chapman:

I like to listen to Youtube videos/podcasts as I drive around and have wished I could find a good, current playlist of all the top worship songs.

I can’t find any! So I made my own on the Worshipflow Youtube channel!

You’ll find playlists for the top CCLI, Praisecharts and CCM radio hits updated every week.

You May Also Like